I just bought these boots recently and did a 3300 km ride, much of it in the rain. The boots are as comfortable as wearing your slippers, but unfortunately they're about as waterproof too. Honestly though, for the price they're hard to beat. I give them 4 stars because they're so damn comfortable and I bought them on sale for $99 CDN. They buckle up easily and they don't look like ski boots! They lose a star because they're definitely not going to keep your feet dry. Btw I had originally bought a pair of $425 boots from another manufacturer but they were so clunky I couldn't feel my shifter or brake pedal.